Last Updated on

When buying a comforter, you will see there are many choices available, and if you’re trying to find the best choice for your needs, two options that might come up are polyester and cotton.

Both of these offer many benefits and are trendy choices, but if you’re struggling to decide which is best, you need to weigh up the pros and cons.

Each has its own positive and negative aspects, so when it comes to finding the best comforter for you, it is essential to have all the information first.

To help you do this, here are our favorite polyester and cotton comforters, as well as essential information on the benefits and downsides of both materials.

 

Polyester Comforters

As an example, take a look at our review of these three polyester comforters:

Bokser Home All-Season Microfiber Fill Down Alternative Polyester Comforter

First on our list is the Bosker Home duvet insert. It is a soft, supple alternative to using a down comforter. The comforter has a plush fill, which is slightly heavier than goose down, making it an excellent choice for staying warm.

This product has a polyester fill. Its cushioned effect makes it a very cozy option that provides a lot of comfort and warmth, especially during the winter months or if you live in a cooler climate. Polyester is a luxurious alternative to down fill.

In addition to this, it has been safety checked and is confirmed as being hypoallergenic. That means that it is free from allergens, as well as harmful chemicals and materials. If you suffer from sensitive skin or are prone to allergies, this comforter will not irritate your skin.

When you are deciding which comforter is best for you, convenience will most likely be an essential factor. And this product provides that. It is easy to care for at home, can be machine-washed and dried, and even has corner tie loops to keep the fill in place for longer.

Overall, this is a great choice. It is available on Amazon in three different sizes: twin, full/queen, and king/cal king-size. This breathable, high-quality product is one of the best polyester alternatives available and comes with free shipping to US customers.

Pros

  • Soft and comfy.
  • Cloud-feel.
  • Plush Alternative Fill.
  • Hypoallergenic.
  • Machine washable.
  • Certified Standard 100 by OEKO – TEX.

Cons

  • It is available in two sizes, twin and queen.
  • It is only available in white color.


LINENSPA All-Season White Down Alternative Quilted Plush Polyester Comforter

This is another great polyester comforter. It has a polyester fill, which works very well as a down alternative. It is soft, warm, durable, and suitable for use all year. Whether you want to stay warm and cozy or cool during the summer months, this product can help.

It has a box stitch design, which, along with the eight built-in corner and side loops, helps the fill to stay securely in place. This can ensure that the polyester comforter stays in the best condition for longer, giving it a fluffed effect, even after years of use.

Not only is the microfiber alternative to fill a warm and comfortable choice, but it is also hypoallergenic. If you are concerned about the effects your bedding is having on your skin, this comforter helps to reduce skin irritation, especially if you suffer from allergies.

In terms of variety, the comforter is available in a range of colors and comes in many sizes: twin, twin XL, full, queen, oversized queen, king, oversized king, and California king. It is also reversible, so you can easily switch to a new color when you want to. For the pastel shade lovers, the comforter can be purchased in twelve dreamy shades. There is a grey-white striped comforter, classic plain white, stone and charcoal, sand and mocha, black and graphite, and gray-white quatrefoiled, and more!

This product is easy to care for. It can be machine washed on a cold, gentle cycle, and it can be either air-dried or machine dried to maintain its freshness and quality. It is also an affordable option, comes with a 3-year warranty and free shipping, and returns for US customers.

Pros

  • Reversible color design.
  • Hypoallergenic product.
  • Machine washable for easier cleaning and maintenance.
  • Box stitch design.
  • Available in varieties of sizes.
  • Soft and fluffy.
  • Lightweight, ideal all-year-round comforter.
  • Eight loops to help the cover stay in place.
  • 3-year warranty.

Cons

  • Quality gets hampered with multiple washes.
  • On rough usage, the filling can fall off.
  • Some customers complained that the stitching on the comforter was sloppy.
  • The thickness may feel less to some users.


LOVO Down Alternative Diamond Quilt Polyester Comforter

The LOVO comforter features on polyester down alternatives that maintain its fluff.

The brushed microfiber outer cover is both soft yet durable. This polyester comforter is available in four colors, baby pink, snow white, pale pink, and purple. All of them will look gorgeous at any bedroom and surely accentuates the classic for the comforter.

This comforter can be used as a stand-alone comforter or as a duvet insert to maintain it better and for a longer time. In this second case, there are conveniently located tie-down points along with the corners for securing it into a duvet cover, making sure that it will not slip out even if you are an active sleeper.

This 10%0 polyester comforter has slightly oversized dimensions that beautiful overhang and convey the luxurious and comfortable nature of the bedding.

The durable craftsmanship is reasonably evident on the hems and double stitching that will definitely extend this comforter’s longevity.

The fabric of this polyester bedding is 100% hypoallergenic, which makes this comforter a perfect choice for those with feather allergies. Besides, this microfiber fill allows for the quilt bedding to be ultimately machine washable simply use cold water and set it on a gentle cycle and either sun dry or tumble dry it on low heat and you are set.

The comforter comes in a vacuum-sealed package to ensure that it is as fresh as it rolled off the factory. For this fact, as soon as you get it, take it out of the package and allow it to fluff out for about an hour to gain its maximum loft.

Pros

  • Color is exactly as it is in the picture.
  • Lightweight and fluffy.
  • Soft and airy.
  • Beautiful patterns.
  • Machine washable for easier cleaning and maintenance.
  • Diamond quilt stitching design.

Cons

  • A bit small for a queen size.


Cotton Comforters

As an example, take a look at our review of these three cotton comforters:

Cottonloft Cotton Filled Medium Warmth Comforter

Cotton can be an amazing alternative to down or other synthetic comforters. And this product is a great example of that. It is made from 100% cotton, is warm and soft, and is made to an extremely high standard. Both the cover and the fill are made of cotton.

The natural, hypoallergenic material makes it an excellent option if you have sensitive skin or suffer from allergies. Plus, its unique cloud stitching helps the filling to stay in place so that you can enjoy it for longer. Even after years of use, it will hold its quality.

It is also lightweight and breathable. Whether you live in a warm or cooler climate, this comforter will help keep you at the right temperature, so you are able to get a better night’s sleep. If you suffer from night sweats, it will keep you cool, dry, and comfortable while you sleep.

The comforter is easy to care for. It can be machine washed using a gentle cycle and cold water. It can also be tumbled or air-dried to keep it fresh. If you are thinking of buying the product, make sure you check all the instructions carefully to make sure you keep it in good condition.

This comforter has many benefits. As you can see, it is a well-made, durable, and a top-quality product that can be used for many years. It is available in two sizes; twin and full size, and even comes with free delivery and returns for your convenience.

Pros

  • Pure cotton.
  • Great in summer as well as in winter.
  • Breathable.
  • Hypoallergenic.
  • Medium weight.

Cons

  • Smelly.
  • A user said that it didn’t fit.


SNOWMAN White Goose Down 100% Cotton Comforter

This affordable down comforter has a 100% cotton cover. The 100% cotton cover is breathable, making the comforter ultra-soft, fluffy, and with a cloud-like feeling.

The Snowman cotton comforter is meant for cold sleepers. This bedding has abundant down filling to challenge the cold weather.

This filling consists of the mix of two types of feathers: 90% 800 fill power white goose down and 10% goose down feathers. The mixture is locked into baffle boxes, which prevent down shedding. The baffles also facilitate the down to remain fluffy and spread the warmth throughout the comforter.

This 100% cotton comforter is available in three sizes, king, queen, and twin size. It also can be found in four gorgeous colors, blue, khaki, white, and gray.

This comforter is a hypoallergenic and anti-dust mite.

It has corner tabs to tie down the duvet covers. The corners are done with special stitching to reinforce them.

It is supposed to be dry-cleaned for the best results.

The consensus is that it’s warm. Given the fill power and amount, its more for the moderate to heavy winter climate. But by the nature of goose down, it’s pretty breathable and cold sleepers can use it in summer too.

Not only does this give you warmth during colder nights, but it also offers a comfortable sleeping experience throughout the whole year. Some other comforters can be uncomfortably loud, but not this one.

The manufacturer recommends dry-cleaning this cotton comforter. You can put it in the machine in a cold, low-temp cycle and allow it to tumble-dry at some personal risk.

The product is packaged in an impenetrable and sturdy plastic with a zippered cover for transport. It might have a faint odor from tight packaging, which escapes when you air it in the shade for a while. It bangs big for the bucks based on the list price.

Pros

  • 90% Goose down + 10% Feather.
  • Hypoallergenic Cotton shell.
  • Very plush feel.
  • High fill amount and exceptionally fluffy.
  • Oversized.
  • Breathable and comfortable cover.
  • It has secure tabs for stability inside the duvet.
  • Light but warm.
  • Baffle channel construction.
  • Both for summer and winter.

Cons

  • Some odor when it first arrives.
  • A bit too large for a queen-sized bed.
  • It is quite heavy.


HOMFY Premium Cotton Comforter

Finally, yet importantly, the HOMFY Premium Cotton Comforter is a soft, breathable product, made from luxury cotton to help you get a more comfortable night’s sleep. It can be used in any climate, and it absorbs moisture like sweat to keep you warm and dry.

The edges of the comforter are double sealed to help keep the filling in place. This makes it more durable and long-lasting; even after washing and drying it, the filling will stay in good condition. It also gives it a better-looking finish.

The classic design of the product gives an elegant, chic look, which is an excellent addition to any bedroom. This, along with the comfort it provides, makes it a perfect choice that will fit well with any type of decor.

It is available in three sizes, which are twin, queen, and king-size. In addition to this, the manufacturer provides US customers with a free 30-day money-back guarantee, free delivery, and a two-year warranty. Therefore, if you are not sure, you know that if there is an issue, it can be returned quickly.

Pros

  • Soft and fluffy.
  • Machine washable and dryable.
  • Breathable.
  • 320 GSM.
  • Box stitched surface.

Cons

  • A user has complained that it was not wide enough to cover his or her bed. A bit small for a king size.
  • Just available in two types of white: classic white and milk-white.


Frequently Asked Questions

Before you buy a comforter, you might have some questions or concerns. You want to ensure you are making the right choice.

To help you do this, here are the answers to some frequently asked questions about cotton and polyester comforters.

Which is better polyester or cotton comforter?

When choosing between polyester and cotton, which is better for you will come down to your personal needs and preferences. Do you prefer human-made or natural materials? What are your priorities? Would you rather have durability or softness?

Polyester, for example, is less breathable than cotton. It also absorbs more moisture. This can make it a poor choice if staying cool is your biggest priority. In addition to this, polyester can be prone to staining and can cause skin irritation in some people.

On the other hand, polyester does not wrinkle in the same way as cotton and is much easier to wash and care for. Also, it tends to last longer and is much more durable. Alternatively, you can choose a blended comforter, which can give you the best of both.

Which type of comforter you go for will ultimately come down to your own preferences. There are plenty of options available for both types of materials, and as you have seen in our reviews, there are some very high-quality comforters available for sale.

What are the benefits of polyester comforters?

Polyester is a popular choice when it comes to comforters. Its durability is what it is best known for. It is an extremely long-lasting choice and is able to retain its shape, even after many years of use. It is also one of the most affordable options, so it’s great if you’re on a tight budget.

Another advantage of choosing polyester is that it is easy to wash at home in a washing machine and can be put in the dryer afterward. It is also much less likely to shrink, wrinkle or fade when you wash it than some other materials, like cotton.

Polyester, as well as other manufactured materials, tend to be built in a way that makes them wind, water, and chill proof. However, it does tend to trap a lot of moisture, so if you live in a warm climate or are prone to night sweating, you may find it uncomfortable.

Another downside to polyester is that it absorbs a lot of oil. This can make it more prone to stains, which can be tough to remove. Additionally, if you have sensitive skin, it can be irritating as polyester fibers attract static electricity.

What are the benefits of cotton comforters?

Cotton is best-known for its softness. When it comes to cotton comforters, however, how soft it will depend on the thread count. As a rule, the higher the thread count, the softer it will be. Therefore, if you choose one with a low thread count, polyester will probably give more comfort.

Cotton tends to be more breathable than polyester. It keeps out moisture, which can help to keep you cool in warmer weather. In addition to this, it can retain its softness over many years; cotton is known for becoming softer over time.

Overall, cotton is more supple than polyester. Besides, it is less likely to cause skin irritation. So if you have sensitive skin or are prone to allergies, it’s a better choice. If you are buying it for a child or baby, it is more suitable as well as the material is much gentler.

Unlike polyester, cotton comforters do not stain very easily. If they do, these stains can easily be removed by using a stain remover or pre-treating them before putting them in the washing machine. They are also less likely to pill.

However, there are a few disadvantages to cotton. For example, it is more likely to wrinkle or shrink when it is washed, and it can become thin after using it every day. It is also a bit more expensive than polyester, so it is important to weigh up the benefits to see if it is worth the extra cost.

What are the benefits of blended materials?

When you are looking for a comforter, you will see that there are products available that are a blend of polyester and cotton. These combine the softness of cotton with the durability of polyester, to try to give you the best of both.

Blended products are not prone to wrinkling or fading, and even when washed in high-temperature water, they do not tend to shrink very much. Additionally, they are often more affordable than pure cotton and generally last a bit longer.

What are the benefits of natural comforters?

Cotton comforters feel great. They are soft, sturdy, and provide a lot of warmth. Nevertheless, if you are prone to allergies or you have sensitive skin, you might be interested in finding an alternative that will not cause skin irritation.

Luckily, there are plenty of hypoallergenic natural comforters that provide all the benefits of cotton, without the irritation. These are often more affordable, as well as being more durable and easier to clean than regular cotton alternatives.

What is the comforter fill?

Before you buy a comforter, it is important to establish what is inside it. This is known as fill. This might be synthetic or natural, and different comforters will use different fillings to give it its warmth and coziness.

Some common terms you might see are:

  • Gel fiber — this is a type of polyester that tends to be lightweight and similar to cotton.
  • Natural fill — natural materials can be used to fill the comforter; this could be wool, silk, bamboo, or other natural material.
  • Synthetic polyester — this is a human-made alternative that is made from hypoallergenic synthetic material.
Both polyester and cotton comforters look excellent and have good user reviews, including remarks on their delicate quality.